Acrylic Walk in Tubs Versus Triple Gel Coat Walk in Tubs | Which is Better

Acrylic Walk in Tubs Versus Triple Gel Coat Walk in Tubs | Which is Better

Acrylic Walk-In Tubs vs. Triple Gel Coat Finished Walk-In Tubs: A Comprehensive Guide

When it comes to choosing the best walk-in tubs for your bathroom, there are several important factors to consider, from safety features and accessibility to material durability and aesthetic appeal. Among the most common materials used for walk-in bathtubs are acrylic and triple gel coat finishes. Both offer distinct advantages, but they also have their downsides. In this guide, we’ll compare acrylic walk-in tubs with triple gel coat finished walk-in tubs, helping you make an informed decision on which one best suits your needs.

What Are Walk-In Tubs?

Before diving into the differences between acrylic and triple gel coat finished walk-in tubs, let’s quickly review what walk-in tubs are and why they’re so popular. Walk-in bathtubs are specially designed for individuals with mobility challenges, offering easy access to the bath through a door that allows you to step into the tub without having to climb over a traditional tub's high edge.

These tubs are particularly beneficial for elderly individuals or those recovering from surgery or injury, as they reduce the risk of slips and falls. Many walk-in tubs also feature hydrotherapy jets, which provide therapeutic benefits by massaging the muscles and improving circulation. Some models even offer heated seats, a luxury feature that further enhances comfort.

Now, let’s break down the two materials typically used in walk-in tubs—acrylic and triple gel coat finishes—and look at their respective pros and cons.

Acrylic Walk-In Tubs

Acrylic walk-in tubs are among the most popular options available today, thanks to their durability, ease of maintenance, and sleek appearance. Acrylic is a lightweight, versatile material that is easy to mold into various shapes and sizes, making it ideal for customizing your walk-in tub.

Pros of Acrylic Walk-In Tubs

  1. Durability and Longevity

Acrylic is known for its exceptional durability. It is resistant to chipping, cracking, and fading, meaning your acrylic walk-in bathtub will retain its beauty for many years with proper care. Acrylic is also highly resistant to stains, so it’s less likely to discolor over time, keeping your tub looking fresh.

  1. Smooth, Glossy Finish

One of the standout features of acrylic walk-in tubs is their smooth, glossy finish. This shiny surface not only enhances the tub's appearance but also makes it easier to clean. The non-porous surface resists bacteria and mold growth, providing a hygienic environment for users. Because it doesn’t absorb moisture, cleaning your acrylic walk-in bath is a breeze.

  1. Lightweight

Compared to other materials, acrylic is relatively lightweight. This makes it easier to install, reducing both installation time and cost. The lightness of the material also allows for easier handling during transport, which can save you money on shipping fees.

  1. Wide Range of Options

Acrylic walk-in tubs come in a wide range of styles, sizes, and colors, allowing you to choose a model that best fits your bathroom and personal style. Many manufacturers offer customizable features such as hydrotherapy jets, heated seats, and aromatherapy features, making your walk-in bath an oasis of relaxation.

  1. Energy Efficiency

Since acrylic is a good insulator, it helps retain heat, making your hydrotherapy walk-in bathtub more energy-efficient. The water stays warmer for longer, allowing you to enjoy longer, more relaxing baths without constantly needing to top off the water.

Cons of Acrylic Walk-In Tubs

  1. Susceptible to Scratches

While acrylic is durable, it can be prone to scratches if not properly cared for. These scratches can dull the surface and make it more difficult to keep the tub looking new. It’s important to avoid abrasive cleaning tools and harsh chemicals to maintain the smooth finish of your acrylic walk-in tub.

  1. Cost

Acrylic walk-in tubs can be more expensive than some other options, particularly when you factor in additional features like hydrotherapy jets or heated seats. However, the long-lasting durability of acrylic means that you’re making an investment that will pay off over time.

  1. Potential for Fading Over Time

Though acrylic is resistant to fading, it can still lose its color if exposed to direct sunlight for extended periods. This is especially true for darker colors, which may show signs of discoloration over time. If you live in an area with lots of sunlight, you may want to consider placing your walk-in bath away from direct light or opting for a lighter color.

Triple Gel Coat Finished Walk-In Tubs

Triple gel coat finished walk-in tubs are another popular option. These tubs feature a gel coat finish that is applied to the surface of the tub in multiple layers, providing a smooth, glossy surface with increased durability.

Pros of Triple Gel Coat Finished Walk-In Tubs

  1. Superior Scratch Resistance

The gel coat finish provides a highly scratch-resistant surface, which means your triple gel coat walk-in bathtub is less likely to show signs of wear and tear compared to other materials. This makes them a great choice for households with children or pets.

  1. Stunning Appearance

The triple gel coat finish gives the tub a sleek, polished appearance that rivals that of acrylic. The smooth surface is easy to clean and resists staining, keeping your tub looking pristine for years.

  1. Affordability

Triple gel coat finished walk-in tubs tend to be more affordable than their acrylic counterparts. If you’re on a budget but still want a high-quality, durable walk-in bath, a gel coat tub could be an excellent option for you.

  1. Long-Lasting Finish

The triple gel coat layers provide an added level of durability. This finish is resistant to fading and discoloration over time, ensuring that your tub maintains its color and shine for years to come.

Cons of Triple Gel Coat Finished Walk-In Tubs

  1. Less Flexible Than Acrylic

While triple gel coat finished walk-in tubs are durable, they are not as flexible as acrylic in terms of customization. Acrylic can be molded into a variety of shapes, while gel coat tubs are typically limited to standard sizes and shapes. This can make it harder to find a walk-in tub that perfectly fits your space.

  1. Heavier

Triple gel coat finished tubs are generally heavier than acrylic tubs, which can make them more difficult to transport and install. This can increase both shipping and installation costs. Additionally, the added weight may put more strain on the floor structure in some homes, especially older buildings.

  1. More Maintenance

While the surface of triple gel coat tubs is relatively easy to clean, it is more susceptible to fading and staining than acrylic. The finish may require periodic maintenance to keep it looking its best. This could involve polishing or waxing to restore the shine and prevent the surface from becoming dull over time.

Which is Right for You?

When deciding between acrylic walk-in tubs and triple gel coat finished walk-in tubs, the right choice depends on your individual needs and preferences. Here’s a quick comparison to help you make an informed decision:

  • If you prioritize customization and a long-lasting, lightweight material, acrylic walk-in tubs are likely your best choice. The versatility, energy efficiency, and low-maintenance nature of acrylic make it a great option for many homeowners.

  • If you’re looking for an affordable option with a durable finish, a triple gel coat finished walk-in bathtub may be the better choice. It’s an excellent option if you’re on a budget but still want a high-quality, sleek-looking tub.

Final Thoughts

Both acrylic walk-in tubs and triple gel coat finished walk-in tubs are great options, each offering distinct advantages. The decision ultimately comes down to your personal preferences, budget, and the specific features you’re looking for in your walk-in tub. Whether you choose an acrylic tub with hydrotherapy jets or a gel coat tub for its scratch-resistant finish, either option can provide you with a safe, comfortable, and luxurious bathing experience.

For more information on the best walk-in tubs and to explore a range of options, visit WalkInTubs4Less.com or call us at 1-888-779-2284(BATH). We offer a wide selection of walk-in baths, including both acrylic and gel coat finished tubs, so you can find the perfect one for your home.

Note: For more details about walk-in tub materials and installation, explore additional reviews from Consumer Reports.

Back to blog